Constructive Discharge After Sexual Harassment in New York
If you resigned because sexual harassment made your working conditions unbearable, you may still have legal claims against your former employer. In some circumstances, the law treats a resignation as the equivalent of being fired. Lawyers call this constructive discharge.
Even if your resignation does not meet the legal standard for constructive discharge, you may still have claims based on the sexual harassment or retaliation that occurred before you left.
1990
Admitted in New York
2007
Argued before the U.S. Supreme Court
1998
Thurgood Marshall Award, NYC Bar
At The Howley Law Firm, we help individuals throughout New York City and New York State understand their rights, evaluate their options, and make informed decisions about what to do next.
Call (212) 601-2728 to find out whether we may be able to help you.
Why Choose The Howley Law Firm for a Constructive Discharge Claim?
The Howley Law Firm is a New York law firm representing individuals in sexual harassment, whistleblower retaliation, and healthcare fraud whistleblower cases. We prepare each employee’s case with the thoroughness a large company would demand of its own lawyers.
John Howley made partner at Kaye Scholer LLP, where for nearly two decades he represented major corporations. Now he and the firm represent employees forced out by harassment, drawing on that background and his oral argument at the U.S. Supreme Court.
We know the arguments employers make when an employee says they were forced out. An employer may say that you quit voluntarily, that you never complained, or that conditions were unpleasant but bearable. It may also point to the months you stayed as a sign that things were not intolerable.
We look closely at your resignation letter, the complaints you made, and the dates, because each one bears on those arguments.
Losing a job this way can affect your income, your references, and your next position. John stays involved in every case the firm takes, and you will get his honest view of your case, weak points included.
John’s experience also includes obtaining significant recoveries for individuals who experienced sexual harassment and other forms of workplace discrimination, including a $1 million sexual harassment settlement involving a live-in nanny.
Does Resigning End My Harassment Claim?
Not by itself. Whether you can successfully pursue a lawsuit depends not on whether you resigned, but why you resigned, what happened before you left, how your employer responded, and which federal, New York State, or New York City laws apply to your case.
We will weigh each of those points with you.
Do not assume that you gave up your claim when you quit.
When Does Quitting Count as Constructive Discharge in New York?
Under federal law, constructive discharge may occur when an employer subjects an employee to discriminatory working conditions so intolerable that a reasonable person in the employee’s position would have felt compelled to resign, and the employee actually resigns.
When constructive discharge is established, the law may treat the resignation as the equivalent of a termination.
New York State and New York City law also recognize constructive-discharge claims, although the applicable standards and consequences must be considered separately.
We evaluate the circumstances leading to your resignation, your employer’s conduct, and the legal claims that may be available.
Why Is Constructive Discharge Hard to Prove Under Federal Law?
Under federal law, constructive discharge takes more than harassment bad enough to create a hostile work environment. Constructive discharge is not established merely because the workplace became unpleasant or stressful.
Even if the circumstances do not meet that higher standard, you may still have claims for the sexual harassment and retaliation that occurred before you left.
Do not assume that falling short of the constructive discharge standard means you have nothing to pursue.
Does Constructive Discharge Change the Money I Can Recover?
Yes. If your resignation qualifies as a constructive discharge, you may be able to recover wages and benefits lost because you were forced to leave your job. Depending on the circumstances, compensation for future lost earnings may also be available.
The fact that an employee resigned does not automatically eliminate the possibility of recovering damages.
Even if you cannot prove constructive discharge, you may still be entitled to compensation for unlawful sexual harassment or retaliation that occurred before you resigned.
The available remedies depend on the evidence, the applicable law, your efforts to find other employment, and the circumstances of your case.
Should I Talk to a Lawyer Before I Resign?
Yes, when you can. Because resigning can affect issues such as damages, unemployment benefits, and litigation strategy, employees should consult an experienced employment lawyer before resigning whenever circumstances permit.
We can help you think through the timing before you decide.
What Should I Do Now If I Have Resigned or Feel Forced to Resign?
Write down when each change in your job began, in order, before the details fade. Seeing the changes in sequence helps us understand what happened.
You can start today:
- list every complaint you made, to whom, and how, since it shows what your employer knew
- hold on to your resignation letter and any answer your employer gave you
- if money kept you in the job longer than you wanted, write that down, since it can explain the timing of your resignation
- save messages from your personal phone, including your side of each exchange
Do not start downloading company data. Preserve what you already lawfully possess, identify where other evidence sits, and leave it there for a lawyer to analyze and advise on.
If a record you need belongs to your employer, write down its title and date, and leave it where it is.
Leaving a job can also affect your health insurance, so if you need medical care, consider arranging it before your coverage changes.
How Long Do I Have to File a Constructive Discharge Claim?
There are strict time limits, and acting early protects your rights.
These are the main deadlines:
- three years to file a complaint with the New York State Division of Human Rights, counted from the discrimination you are complaining about
- three years to file a lawsuit in court under the State Human Rights Law
If New York City law applies to you, these are the City deadlines:
- three years after the harassing conduct to file a complaint about gender-based harassment with the New York City Commission on Human Rights
- one year to file a complaint with the New York City Commission on Human Rights about anything other than gender-based harassment, such as retaliation, counted from the act you are complaining about
- three years to file a lawsuit in court under the New York City Human Rights Law, counted from the discrimination you are complaining about
These are the federal deadlines:
- 300 days from the harassment to file a charge, a formal complaint, with the federal Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC). This applies if the harassment happened while you worked in New York for a private employer or a state or local government that Title VII covers
- 90 days to file a lawsuit in federal court after you are given a right-to-sue notice. This applies to a charge against a private employer or a state or local government. The EEOC gives that notice, or the U.S. Attorney General when the employer is a government
Title VII is the main federal law against job discrimination. It covers an employer only if it had 15 or more employees on each working day of at least 20 calendar weeks. All 20 weeks must be in the current calendar year, or all in the year before. If you first filed with a State or City agency, your time to file with the EEOC can be shorter.
Under federal law, the clock for a constructive discharge claim starts when you give notice that you are resigning, not on your last day of work.
Because the date you gave notice can matter, we can help you check which of these deadlines may apply.
Questions About Constructive Discharge
Does New York State Law Protect Me If My Employer Is Small?
Yes. New York State’s Human Rights Law covers all employers in the state, whatever their size.
What Does It Cost to Talk to You About a Forced Resignation?
There is no charge for the initial consultation with an experienced lawyer. We handle most cases on a contingency-fee basis. In those cases, our attorneys’ fees depend on obtaining a recovery. We will explain the fee arrangement and responsibility for litigation expenses before you decide whether to retain us.
Speak With a Constructive Discharge Lawyer in New York
You do not need to have resigned already to talk with us about it.
We will review the events behind your decision, give you a candid assessment, and leave the choice about your job with you.
If you have not resigned yet, it may be particularly important to get legal advice before you give notice.
If the harassment involved a job benefit tied to a sexual demand, see quid pro quo sexual harassment. Before you call, see what to bring to your consultation. For a short answer to a common question, see can I sue for sexual harassment if I quit my job.
Our team answers calls 24 hours a day, seven days a week. After gathering some basic information, we will determine whether your matter is one our firm may be able to help with. If it is, we will arrange a free, confidential telephone consultation with an experienced attorney.