Third-Party Sexual Harassment by Customers and Clients in New York
When a customer, client, patient, or vendor sexually harasses you, your employer usually still decides your shifts, your accounts, and whom you must deal with.
1990
Admitted in New York
2007
Argued before the U.S. Supreme Court
1998
Thurgood Marshall Award, NYC Bar
We can help you decide how to respond when the harasser is someone the business serves or buys from.
Our clients in these cases work throughout New York City and New York State.
Why Choose The Howley Law Firm When a Customer or Client Harasses You?
The Howley Law Firm is a New York law firm representing individuals in sexual harassment, whistleblower retaliation, and healthcare fraud whistleblower cases. Businesses rely on large law firms when a claim is made against them, and an individual employee deserves representation of the same standard.
Kaye Scholer LLP, where John Howley rose to partner, relied on him for nearly two decades to represent major corporations. His career includes a 2007 argument in the U.S. Supreme Court, and today he represents people harassed by the customers and patients they serve.
Three defenses are common: the employer had no control over the customer, you never asked for help, or it could not turn that person away.
Questions we ask about what your employer could have done:
01
could the customer, patient, or patron have been warned or barred?
02
could your section, route, account, or shift have changed?
03
could a vendor have been asked to send someone else?
04
could someone have stayed with you so you never faced that person alone?
05
had other staff raised concerns about this person before?
Your tips, your commissions, and your accounts can depend on the same customer, and so can your safety at work. Every case the firm takes on is one John works on himself. If something in your situation works against you, he tells you.
John’s experience also includes obtaining significant recoveries for individuals who experienced sexual harassment and other forms of workplace discrimination, including a $1 million sexual harassment settlement involving a live-in nanny.
Which Laws Protect You From Sexual Harassment at Work in New York?
If you work in New York, up to three laws can apply to harassment at work, and each one sets its own bar.
If you work in New York State, State law protects you from sexual harassment at work.
New York State’s Human Rights Law covers all employers in the state, whatever their size.
If you work in New York City, the City’s Human Rights Law also protects you from sexual harassment. For harassment because of your gender, it covers employers of every size. These protections do not apply to a job where your employer is your own parent, spouse, registered domestic partner or child.
Under City law, gender includes your sex, gender identity and gender expression.
We will look at where you work and who your employer is, and which of these laws may protect you.
Is My Employer Responsible When a Customer, Client, or Vendor Harasses Me?
Possibly.
An employer may be legally responsible for sexual harassment by someone who does not work for the company.
The rules depend on the applicable law and the circumstances.
Important questions include whether the employer knew or should have known about the harassment, what steps it could reasonably have taken to protect you, and how it responded.
An employer cannot necessarily avoid responsibility simply by saying that the harasser was a customer or that the company wanted to preserve the business relationship.
We examine what your employer knew, the options available to it, and whether its response was reasonable and effective.
Even if the customer is still coming in and nothing has changed, you can call us. Call (212) 601-2728 to find out whether we may be able to help you.
Does New York Law Require Me to Report a Customer's Harassment Before Filing a Claim?
No.
New York law does not require an employee to report internally before filing a legal claim, but doing so can still strengthen the case.
You can speak with an attorney before reporting the harassment to your employer.
Whether and when to report the conduct can affect your legal rights and your employer’s responsibility.
A report may help establish that the employer knew what was happening and had an opportunity to take appropriate action. However, a written complaint is not the only way to establish that an employer knew or should have known about harassment.
We can help you evaluate whether, when, and how to report the conduct, especially if you are concerned about losing income, customers, assignments, or opportunities because you complained.
What Should I Keep If a Customer or Client Is Harassing Me?
Start a written record outside work today.
Your record should cover:
01
each incident’s date and location, the person’s words or conduct, and the staff on duty
02
the harasser’s name, or how staff refer to that customer
03
each time you told someone at work, and what happened next
A customer’s exact words and the date of each visit are hard to recall months later.
If this customer has your personal number, screenshot each text, with your replies, and save each voicemail before it can be deleted.
Some records, such as schedules, bookings, or camera footage, may sit in your employer’s systems. Tell us they exist and where, and leave them there.
Do not start downloading company data. Preserve what you already lawfully possess, identify where other evidence sits, and leave it there for a lawyer to analyze and advise on.
Preserve the evidence you already have, but speak with an employment lawyer before copying, downloading, or removing confidential company records.
A doctor can help with sleep or other health problems that come from facing this customer, whatever you decide about reporting.
What Are the Deadlines for a Third-Party Harassment Claim?
There are strict time limits, and acting early protects your rights.
These are the main deadlines:
- three years to file a complaint with the New York State Division of Human Rights, counted from the discrimination you are complaining about
- three years to file a lawsuit in court under the State Human Rights Law
If New York City law applies to you, these are the City deadlines:
- three years after the harassing conduct to file a complaint about gender-based harassment with the New York City Commission on Human Rights
- one year to file a complaint with the New York City Commission on Human Rights about anything other than gender-based harassment, such as retaliation, counted from the act you are complaining about
- three years to file a lawsuit in court under the New York City Human Rights Law, counted from the discrimination you are complaining about
These are the federal deadlines:
- 300 days from the harassment to file a charge, a formal complaint, with the federal Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC). This applies if the harassment happened while you worked in New York for a private employer or a state or local government that Title VII covers
- 90 days to file a lawsuit in federal court after you are given a right-to-sue notice. This applies to a charge against a private employer or a state or local government. The EEOC gives that notice, or the U.S. Attorney General when the employer is a government
Title VII is the main federal law against job discrimination. It covers an employer only if it had 15 or more employees on each working day of at least 20 calendar weeks. All 20 weeks must be in the current calendar year, or all in the year before. If you first filed with a State or City agency, your time to file with the EEOC can be shorter.
If a federal agency employs you, tell us when you call and we will work out which deadlines apply to your job.
Common Questions About Third-Party Harassment
Can I Be Punished for Reporting a Customer's Harassment?
Not lawfully. If your employer retaliates against you for reporting sexual harassment, that retaliation is a separate legal violation.
Can I Prove a Customer's Harassment Without Witnesses?
You can win a sexual harassment case based principally, or even entirely, on your own testimony. There is no rule requiring texts, recordings, eyewitnesses, or other documentary corroboration.
Your own testimony can be important evidence. We may also be able to identify other evidence supporting your account, including work schedules, customer records, security footage, previous complaints, or people you told about the harassment.
You do not need to gather all the evidence before contacting us.
Can My Employer Require Me to Keep Working With the Customer Who Harassed Me?
Not necessarily. An employer’s responsibility depends on the circumstances, including what it knows about the harassment and what steps it can reasonably take to protect you.
Depending on the situation, appropriate measures might include warning the customer, arranging for another employee to handle the account, changing assignments without penalizing you, restricting the customer’s access, or ending the business relationship.
An employer does not necessarily satisfy its legal obligations simply by telling you that the customer is important to the business.
We can evaluate whether your employer’s response was reasonable and whether additional protection may be available.
What Does It Cost to Talk to a Lawyer About a Customer Who Harassed Me?
There is no charge for the initial consultation with an experienced lawyer.
We handle most cases on a contingency-fee basis. In those cases, our attorneys’ fees depend on obtaining a recovery. We will explain the fee arrangement and responsibility for litigation expenses before you decide whether to retain us.
Talk to a Third-Party Harassment Lawyer in New York
Calling us does not require that you have reported the customer first.
Tell us what this customer did, and we will explain which laws may help and what your choices are. If your manager wants you to keep serving the same person, it may help to get advice first.
Harassment can also come from inside the company; see sexual harassment by a supervisor and sexual harassment by a co-worker. Harassment by a customer can create a hostile work environment, and you can also read about quid pro quo harassment, where a job benefit is tied to a sexual demand.
Our team answers calls 24 hours a day, seven days a week. After gathering some basic information, we will determine whether your matter is one our firm may be able to help with. If it is, we will arrange a free, confidential telephone consultation with an experienced attorney.