Whistleblower Rewards Lawyer in New York
If you have evidence that a provider is falsely billing Medicare, Medicaid or another government healthcare program, we can help you bring it forward.
Under the federal and New York False Claims Acts, if the case produces a settlement or judgment, the whistleblower generally receives a percentage of the government’s recovery.
You may still work for the provider, and you may not have told anyone yet. That is a good time to talk.
1990
New York bar
2006
Supreme Court bar
All four
NY federal districts
1998
Thurgood Marshall Award, NYC Bar
What Healthcare Fraud Cases Do We Bring?
We take cases where you have evidence of fraud on Medicare, Medicaid or another government healthcare program. We represent individuals in healthcare fraud reward cases in federal courts anywhere in the United States.
The healthcare schemes we have brought cases over include:
urgent care centers billing a routine visit as a longer one, or a nurse practitioner’s work at physician rates
diagnostic tests run on every patient with no individual medical reason
nursing homes billing rehabilitation therapy a resident did not need, to stretch out the stay
nursing homes whose care was so poor that the government did not get what it paid for
kickbacks to patients and providers, and physician self-referral arrangements
hyperbaric oxygen treatment continued after it stopped being medically justified
ambulance and medical transport billed at a higher level than the patient needed, or for trips that never happened
What we weigh first is not the dollar size of the fraud. It is whether the evidence shows a pattern and practice rather than one billing mistake.
What Is a Whistleblower Reward?
Under the federal and New York False Claims Acts, the whistleblower’s share comes out of what is actually recovered in the case or settlement, not out of the amount of fraud alleged. The exact percentage depends on the circumstances, including how substantially the whistleblower contributed to the case.
These cases can take several years, particularly when the alleged fraud is complex.
How Does a Qui Tam Case Work?
Investigation
A qui tam case is the lawsuit a whistleblower brings on the government’s behalf. It begins with a confidential investigation by your lawyer. We determine how the fraud worked, which government programs lost money, who was involved, and what evidence can prove it. If the case is strong enough, we prepare a detailed complaint and provide the government with the evidence supporting the allegations.
Filed under seal
Under federal law, when a whistleblower brings a False Claims Act case, the complaint is filed under seal. It stays sealed for at least 60 days and is not served on the defendant until the court orders it. The government can ask the court to extend the seal for good cause shown.
The government decides
Under the federal False Claims Act, at the end of the investigation, the government may intervene, meaning it takes primary responsibility for prosecuting the case, or decline to intervene. A declination does not necessarily end the case. The whistleblower may be able to continue prosecuting the case with private counsel.
Have evidence of billing fraud? Talk it through with a lawyer in a free, confidential consultation.
Will My Identity Stay Secret If I Report Medicare Fraud?
While a False Claims Act case is under seal, the complaint is not served on the provider, but sealed is not the same as anonymous. Once the court lifts the seal, the complaint can be served on the provider.
While the case is sealed, treat it as confidential. Do not discuss it with co-workers, supervisors, friends or reporters, or on social media.
What Do We Ask First About a Reward Case?
We ask two questions first. Is another case on the same fraud pending, or have the facts already been disclosed in public? And what evidence do you have that ties the wrongdoing to claims for government money?
Under the federal and New York False Claims Acts, while a whistleblower’s case is pending, no one but the government can bring a related case based on the same facts.
Under federal law, a court must dismiss a False Claims Act case if substantially the same allegations were already publicly disclosed in a federal hearing in which the government is a party, in a federal report, hearing, audit or investigation, or in the news media. That does not apply if the government opposes dismissal, or if you are an original source of the information. New York’s False Claims Act has a similar rule, and it also counts state and local government hearings, reports and audits.
Under the federal False Claims Act, an original source is someone who either voluntarily gave the government the information before it was publicly disclosed, or whose knowledge is independent of and materially adds to what was disclosed and who voluntarily gave it to the government before filing.
Answering the second question starts with what is already in your hands from your own job. It is not a reason to go looking for more.
Preserve the evidence you already have, but speak with an employment lawyer before copying, downloading, or removing confidential company records.
How Long Do You Have to Bring a Reward Case?
Under the federal False Claims Act, a case must be filed within six years of the false claim, or within three years after the responsible federal official knew or should have known the key facts, whichever is later. Either way, it can never be filed more than ten years after the false claim. Under New York’s False Claims Act, a case must be filed within ten years of the violation.
There are strict time limits, and acting early protects your rights. We check every deadline that applies to you in the first conversation.
Why Talk to a Lawyer Before You Report?
In a reward case, most of what a lawyer adds happens before anything is filed. Which law applies, who is told first and whether you can show you are an original source are all decided early. So is whether a report inside the company helps or hurts.
Do not start downloading company data. Preserve what you already lawfully possess, identify where other evidence sits, and leave it there for a lawyer to analyze and advise on.
Can You Still Bring a Case If You Took Part in the Fraud?
Taking part does not end a claim on its own. Under the federal False Claims Act, a court can reduce the share of a whistleblower who planned and started the fraud. A whistleblower convicted of a crime for their role in it is dismissed from the case and gets no share.
Why The Howley Law Firm
We start with what you saw, what the government paid and what the provider did next. Then we tell you plainly whether we see a case.
John Howley spent nearly two decades at Kaye Scholer LLP, where he represented major corporations. Today, he uses that experience to represent whistleblowers. We know how hospitals and drug companies bill, and how their lawyers answer a fraud claim. We build the complaint to meet that answer before it comes.
John Howley has taught False Claims Act: Enforcement Trends in Healthcare Fraud, a Lawline course for other lawyers.
John remains personally involved in the cases the firm accepts.
Which Reward Cases Don't We Take?
Not every concern about billing becomes a case, and we will tell you so if yours does not. That can happen where:
- you suspect the billing is false but have no evidence of what was actually billed
- the fraud involves money other than a government healthcare program
- the problem was a single error rather than a pattern
We do not take SEC, IRS, CFTC or anti-money-laundering reward cases, New York tax fraud cases, or False Claims Act cases outside healthcare. Nor do we take medical abuse claims against a doctor or hospital, or professional license defense. If yours is one of those, we will say so in the first conversation and try to point you to a lawyer who handles it.
Questions About Whistleblower Reward Cases
Is It a Retaliation Case or a Reward Case?
It can be either, or both. A reward case is about fraud on the government. A retaliation case is about what was done to you for reporting. We represent individuals in whistleblower retaliation cases across New York.
Do You Have to Quit Your Job?
You do not need to quit to talk to us. Talk to us before you decide, because leaving a job is hard to undo.
Talk to The Howley Law Firm About a Healthcare Fraud Reward Case
You do not need to have reported anything to call us, and you do not need your evidence in order.
Tell us what you saw in the billing, and we will help you work out what to do first.
There is no charge for the initial consultation with an experienced lawyer. We handle most cases on a contingency-fee basis. In those cases, our attorneys’ fees depend on obtaining a recovery. We will explain the fee arrangement and responsibility for litigation expenses before you decide whether to retain us.